As the early days of 2026 unfold, BYU's football program is already drawing considerable attention. The Cougars have strategically fortified their squad with promising talent from the transfer portal, reinforcing the offensive line and securing a valuable replacement at linebacker. However, an even more significant development has been the team's impressive ability to retain its core roster. All pivotal players from the 2025 season, including star quarterback Bear Bachmeier and dynamic running back LJ Martin, are confirmed to return. This continuity, a rarity in today's collegiate football landscape influenced by the transfer portal and NIL deals, has ignited a fervent sense of optimism within the fan base and among sports analysts alike.
BYU's Strategic Moves and Unprecedented Optimism for the 2026 Season
In a period typically marked by player movement, Brigham Young University's football team has distinguished itself through strategic roster management, fueling high hopes for the upcoming 2026 season. Dave McCann, a distinguished sportswriter and columnist for the Deseret News, alongside being a play-by-play announcer for BYUtv/ESPN+, recently offered profound insights into the Cougars' current standing. His observations, shared during a 'Y's Guys' podcast session, underscore the program's remarkable stability.
McCann highlighted the team's success in retaining key talent as particularly noteworthy. Figures like quarterback Bear Bachmeier, running back LJ Martin, linebacker Isaiah Glasker, and corner Evan Johnson, all instrumental in the 2025 campaign, are set to continue their journey with the Cougars. This level of retention is a significant achievement, especially given the dynamic landscape of college football, where the transfer portal and Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) opportunities often lead to extensive player shifts. This continuity suggests a strong foundational element for BYU's aspirations.
Furthermore, McCann delved into the ramifications of Kyle Whittingham's departure from Utah to Michigan, noting its potential impact on the storied BYU-Utah rivalry. He mused that this transition might temper the rivalry's intensity, especially with Morgan Scalley stepping into Whittingham's former role. Scalley's more outspoken nature, in contrast to Whittingham's measured approach, is anticipated to bring a fresh dynamic to the rivalry. McCann also reflected on Scalley's recent appearance at the Huntsman Center, where BYU fans humorously overshadowed his speech with 'Let's Go Cougars' chants, an incident he views as a memorable chapter in the rivalry's folklore rather than an offense.
The promotion of Kelly Poppinga to BYU's defensive coordinator position and the formation of his new staff were also subjects of discussion. McCann views this as a judicious decision, emphasizing Poppinga's existing familiarity with the defense and the expected increased involvement of head coach Kalani Sitake in defensive strategies. The retention of Gary Andersen, a seasoned mentor to the defensive coaching staff, was also deemed crucial, providing invaluable experience and leadership.
Regarding individual player impact, the return of LJ Martin for his senior year is seen as a colossal boost to BYU's prospects for a Big 12 championship. Martin's exceptional vision and comprehensive skill set as a running back are expected to be pivotal. The pairing of Bachmeier and Martin is regarded as one of the most formidable offensive duos in the Big 12. Additionally, the acquisition of USC transfer Walker Lyons at tight end is lauded as a substantial gain, signaling a revitalization of the tight end position in BYU's offensive scheme.
McCann's preseason predictions place BYU as a strong contender, ranking them around third in the Big 12 and within the top 10 to 15 nationally. This optimism, he believes, is unprecedented for BYU football fans. The combination of Bachmeier's high potential, robust roster retention, and shrewd coaching adjustments paints a picture of a program on the cusp of significant achievement. The collective efforts of Kalani Sitake, the general manager, and individuals like Justin Anderson in orchestrating this stability have garnered considerable commendation.
This period of strategic enhancement and sustained talent retention for BYU football truly encapsulates a moment of vibrant possibility. The discussions by sports commentators and the buzz among the fanbase highlight a confluence of factors contributing to this unprecedented wave of optimism. It's a testament to effective leadership, astute player management, and a clear vision for competitive success. The Cougars are not just preparing for another season; they are building a foundation for sustained excellence, promising an exhilarating journey for their supporters and a compelling narrative for college football enthusiasts.