In a recent legal development, the iconic rock band Mötley Crüe has achieved a significant victory in its dispute with former guitarist Mick Mars. A retired judicial official concluded that the band members were justified in their decision to remove Mars from his official roles within Mötley Crüe Inc., following his withdrawal from a global tour in 2022 due to a debilitating bone disease.
The contention arose after Mars, at 74 years old, announced his inability to continue touring due to ankylosing spondylitis, a painful and disfiguring condition. Despite his claims of being available for studio work and residencies, the band proceeded with his termination. This led to a contentious legal battle, culminating in a recent arbitration ruling in Los Angeles.
The arbitrator’s decision affirmed the band's right to dismiss Mars and mandated that he reimburse $750,030 from an advance, attributed to his absence from 69 live performances. Furthermore, Mars was directed to divest his ownership shares in the group to Nikki Sixx, Tommy Lee, and Vince Neil for $505,737. After these financial adjustments, Mötley Crüe is set to receive a net payment of $244,293.
Sasha Frid, the lead counsel for Mötley Crüe, emphasized that the lawsuit was initiated to safeguard the band's integrity and heritage. He stated that the ruling validated the band's actions both legally and financially, as all of Mars' claims were rejected and the existing agreements were upheld.
Conversely, Ed McPherson, Mars' attorney, expressed strong disapproval of the verdict, calling it unjust. McPherson argued that the band treated Mars unfairly, especially given his long-standing health issues. He highlighted Mars' willingness to contribute in alternative capacities and questioned the equity of his removal after 43 years of service without continued compensation.
Mars had previously vocalized his indignation, accusing his former bandmates of attempting to strip him of his legacy and ownership. He asserted his pivotal role in the band's formation, including selecting the lead singer and naming the group. Mars also alleged that his bandmates utilized pre-recorded tracks during their 2022 reunion tour, a claim the band vehemently denied. Nikki Sixx, in response, stated that pre-recorded elements were necessary due to Mars' alleged performance issues, asserting the band's continuous support for him while condemning his current attempts to discredit them.
The band's legal representation further solidified their stance by issuing a press release confirming that Mars had admitted the falsity of his prior statements under oath. His own expert corroborated that the band performed live, leading Mars to formally retract his earlier accusations during his testimony.
The legal resolution marks a new chapter for Mötley Crüe, as they navigate their future without a founding member. The outcome underscores the complexities and high stakes involved in disputes within established musical groups, particularly when health issues and financial agreements intersect.